September 2026 Master Class
Registration is Now Open
Closes Wed. Sept. 9 Midnight Eastern

Two-for-One Critiques

Two perspectives. One stronger manuscript.

What We Offer

Receive two independent critiques of your work from Write2Ignite reviewers, with thoughtful feedback on your manuscript’s strengths and opportunities for improvement.

$60 standard | $45 W2I members

Why We Offer Critiques

If you’re fairly new to the writing business or trying out a different genre, you may wonder whether or not you’re doing it right. Or maybe you have a manuscript that you feel is almost — but not quite — working, and you’re not sure why. What can you do? Get a professional critique, of course!

What to Expect

Two-for-One Critiques are available for the fee of $60, or a discounted fee of $45 for our members! One manuscript will be critiqued independently by two members of our faculty or Planning Team (see page limits at the bottom of this page).

A critique will give you a thorough review of the strengths and weaknesses of your writing, offer suggestions for improvement, and possibly help you identify potential markets. If you have questions before submitting, please contact Brenda Covert at Two4One@write2ignite.com.

Focus

Instead of focusing on mechanical errors in grammar, spelling, and punctuation, our critiques will focus on the meat of your story. We will point out strengths and weaknesses of the manuscript and make suggestions for improvement. These suggestions may include any of the following:

  • Point of view
  • Plot points
  • Timeline
  • Word choice
  • Character authenticity
  • Age appropriateness for intended audience
  • Theme
  • Premise
  • Dialogue
  • Marketability
  • Structure
  • Readability
  • Beginning hook
  • Endings and character arcs

Guidelines

Manuscript Format for Critiques

All manuscripts should be 12-pt, Times New Roman, double-spaced (unless otherwise noted), with one-inch margins. Include your name, email, the title of your piece, type of manuscript, and the page number on each of your manuscript’s pages. (See page limit below.)

Types of Manuscripts

  • Young adult/middle grade novel: One-page query or synopsis (single-spaced) and the first pages of the manuscript (double-spaced). Ten pages total.
  • Nonfiction children’s book: Chapter outline, proposal and/or query letter (single-spaced) and the first pages of the manuscript (double-spaced). Ten pages total.
  • Picture book: Complete manuscript up to 1,000 words.
  • Early reader/chapter book: First chapters up to 10 pages.
  • Nonfiction article: 1,200 word limit.
  • Short story: 1,200 word limit.
  • Poetry: 5 poems equal 1 critique; 40-line limit for each poem.
  • Devotional: 500-word limit each; up to four devotionals per critique.
  • Curriculum: A table of contents and 2–5 chapters; up to 10 pages
    Activity book/pages—Up to 10 pages.

Our Perspective

Write2Ignite serves writers of children’s and young adult literature from a Christian perspective. Our critiques focus on the craft of writing, the strength of the manuscript, and its intended audience, informed by our mission and values.

You don’t need to agree with our Statement of Faith to request a critique. We do ask that you understand the perspective from which our feedback is offered.

Read Write2Ignite’s Statement of Faith

If you’re uncertain whether your manuscript is a good fit for our critique service, please contact Brenda Covert before submitting payment.

How to Submit

  1. Review the manuscript guidelines.
  2. Complete your payment below.
  3. Email your manuscript to Brenda Covert.

Our Write2Ignite Two-for-One Critique Service does not guarantee the marketability of your manuscript. We believe our insights and comments will improve and strengthen your work. But, ultimately, only you can decide what advice to take and how to revise your manuscript.

Write2Ignite reserves the right to decline manuscripts that fall outside the scope of our critique service. If we are unable to accept your manuscript, your critique fee will be refunded in full.

Already a Write2Ignite Member?

Sign in using the account associated with your W2I membership to receive your $45 member rate. If you’re already signed in under a different account, you can request a secure login link for your membership account.

Not a member? Continue below to request your critique at the $60 standard rate.

Two-for-One Critiques

Include your name, email address, manuscript title, type of manuscript, and page number on each page. Upload your manuscript as an editable word processing document. Submit one manuscript per request.

Payment


Payments are processed securely through PayPal. You can use an eligible credit or debit card without creating a PayPal account.

No payment items has been selected yet